Why is inulin used in ice cream?
In this review, I will cover the different types of inulin products available, their functional properties in ice cream, their health-promoting properties, and the possible side-effects of overconsumption.
You might also like to read:
Key Points
Sugar can be reduced by 30% with an equivalent amount of oligofructose.
Fat can be reduced by 50% with 5% native inulin.
Long-chain inulin is a better fat replacer, has a greater influence on air incorporation, creaminess perception, and melting resistance, and is better at extending shelf-life than oligofructose.
20g per day of inulin, or 5g to 10g per day of oligofructose, is well tolerated by adults.
Both inulin and oligofructose contibute fewer calories (2 kcal/g) compared to fat (9.45 kcal/g) and sucrose (4 kcal/g).
1. Introduction
Inulin is a naturally occurring carbohydrate widely found in nature in a variety of plants and in some bacteria and fungi. It has always been part of the normal human diet as it naturally occurs in several fruits and vegetables, including leeks, onions, garlic, asparagus, Jerusalem artichokes, bananas, dahlias, yacon, and chicory1. The average daily consumption has been estimated to be between 3g and 11g in Europe1 and between 1g and 4g in the USA2. It is classified as a food or food ingredient, not as an additive, in all EU countries and has GRAS (Generally Recognised as Safe) status in the US3.
2. Different grades of inulin
The most widely used source of inulin in the food industry is chicory. The production process basically consists of three steps: 1. extraction of the naturally occurring inulin from chicory roots in a manner very similar to the extraction of sucrose from sugar beets; 2. purification to remove impurities; and 3. evaporation and spray drying.
There are several commercial grades of inulin available, their functional attributes being linked, to a substantial extent, to their degree of polymerisation (DP). The most common are: 1. native inulin; 2. short-chain oligofructose; and 3. long-chain high performance (HP) inulin.
2.1 Native inulin
Native, or standard (ST-inulin), inulin, as it is present in chicory, has a DP ranging from 2 to 65, with an average of about 101. It is available as a white, odourless powder that has a bland, neutral taste without any off-flavour or aftertaste. Native inulin contains 6-10% sugars represented as glucose, fructose, and sucrose and is, therefore, slightly sweet (10% sweetness in comparison to table sugar)3.
2.2 Short-chain oligofructose
The partial enzymatic hydrolysis of native inulin produces a short-chain fraction known as oligofructose, a subgroup of inulin. This product has a DP of 2-10, with an average of 4, and is commercially available as a syrup with a dry matter content of 75%51. It has a sweetness profile similar to that of table sugar with a very clean taste without any lingering effect, and has about 30 - 50% of the sweetness of table sugar5.
2.2.1 Sugar reduction
Short-chain oligofructose is used in ice cream production primarily as a low-calorie sugar subsitute. Soukoulis et al. (2010)6 were able to replace 30% of the sucrose in full-fat ice cream with an equivalent amount of oligofructose. The researchers reported smaller ice crystal sizes, increased overrun (the amount of air that is whipped into ice cream), a decrease in air cell size, reduction of iciness, and increased creaminess in the sugar-reduced samples containing oligofructose. The ice cream was, however, reported to be harder than the 100% sucrose control.
2.3 Long-chain inulin
By applying physical separation techniques, long-chain, ‘high performance’ (HP) inulin is produced, with an average DP of 25 and a molecular distribution ranging from 11 to 605. This product does not contribute sweetness.
2.3.1 Fat reduction
Inulin is an excellent low-calorie fat replacer. When mixed with water or milk, it forms a particle gel network, resulting in a smooth, creamy texture and a fat-like mouthfeel that can be incorporated into foods to replace up to 100% of the fat7. This gel network is composed of a tori-dimensional network of insoluble sub-micron crystalline inulin particles in water. Large amounts of water are immobilised in this network, giving it its smooth and creamy texture8. HP inulin with long chain and high molecular weight is the most desirable as a fat replacer, having double the fat-mimetic property of standard inulin with no sweetness contribution5.
Pintor et al. (2017)9 investigated the reduction of both fat and sugar in ice cream using agave inulin (the DP of which was not published). The researchers found that agave inulin (3%) can be employed to reduce fat from 10% to 7% (30% reduction) and sugar from 15 to 13.2% (12% reduction) in the formulation of low-fat reduced-sugar ice cream. Similarly, El-Nagar et al. (2002)10 were able to reduce the fat content in a yog-ice cream from 10% to 5% (50% reduction) using 5% native inulin (DP 12-13). The researchers found that the sensory attribute ratings for the reduced-fat yog-ice cream containing 5% inulin resembled that of the high fat product.
2.3.2 Decrease hardness of low-fat ice cream
Lowering the fat content in the formulation of low-fat ice cream results in ice cream that is harder. This is because as the amount of fat is reduced, the amount of frozen water increases, resulting in a harder product. Adding oligofructose, native inulin, and long-chain inulin to a low-fat ice cream mix will depress its freezing point (the difference between 0°C (32°F) and the temperature at which water in an ice cream mix first begins to freeze15), resulting in a reduction in the amount of frozen water and, consequently, softer texture50 10. Oligofructose depresses the freezing point of an ice cream mix more than native and long-chain inulin and will, therefore, produce softer ice cream.
2.3.3 Reduce the caloric value of ice cream
Oligofructose, standard inulin, and HP inulin are low caloric food ingredients with a lower caloric value compared to fat and sucrose. In 2008, the European Union adopted an energy value of 2 kcal/g for all dietary fibres, including inulin and oligofructose11 12. Similarly, Health Canada 13 adopted this value and the US FDA has recommended it in its guidance for industry14. This compares to 9.45 kcal/g for fat and 4 kcal/g for sucrose15. Oligofructose, standard, and HP inulin can, therefore, be used to produce healthier ice cream with fewer calories by replacing a portion of the fat or sugar.
2.3.4 Viscosity enhancement
Viscosity can be loosely defined as the thickness of a liquid, with thicker liquids having higher viscosities (honey has a higher viscosity than water for example). In general, as the viscosity of an ice cream mix increases, the perception of creaminess and resistance to melting increases15. Several studies have shown that inulin addition to an ice cream mix increases its viscosity compared to a control mix without inulin16 17 18. This is due to the ability of inulin and oligofructose to hydrate and bind water19. Long-chain HP inulin produces more viscous mixes than oligofructose and native inulin20 16 21.
When inulin is added to a reduced-fat mix and its viscosity compared to that of a full-fat mix without inulin, however, results appear to be mixed. El-Nagar et al. (2002)10 reported a significant increase in the viscosity of low-fat (5%) yog-ice cream fortified with 5%, 7%, and 9% native inulin (DP 12-13) that was greater than the high fat (10% fat) control mix wihtout inulin. Similarly, Acia et al. (2011)22 found that a 50:50 blend of short- and long-chain inulin at 5.5% produced a low-fat dessert (<0.1% data-preserve-html-node="true" fat) that was creamier and thicker, which idicated a higher viscosity, than the control full-fat (2.8% fat) dessert. Akalin et al. (2008)23, however, reported that a reduced-fat (6%) and a low-fat (3%) ice cream with 4% long-chain inulin (DP>20) had a lower viscosity than a 10% fat regular ice cream without inulin.
2.3.5 Increase overrun and melting resistance
Most ice cream studies have demonstrated that inulin substantially enhances overrun and related properties such as foam stabilisation, melting resistance, and shape retention9 10 23 24. High overrun is related to higher viscosities that promote more efficient air incorporation and the formation of smaller air cells25 17.
2.3.6 Extend shelf-life
Ice crystal size is a critical factor in the development of smooth and creamy ice cream26. Smooth and creamy ice cream requires the majority of ice crystals to be small, around 10 to 20 µm in size. If many crystals are larger than this, ice cream will be perceived as being coarse or icy15 27. During distribution and storage, ice and lactose crystals grow and undergo recrystallisation, which eventually leads to coarse or icy texture. Recrystallisation is defined as “any change in number, size, shape… of crystals [during storage]”28) and basically involves small crystals disappearing, large crystals growing, and crystals fusing together.
The 3 main types of recrystallisation are isomass, migratory, and accretive recrystallisation29. Isomass recrystallisation is the change in shape of a crystal without change in mass. Accretion is the joining together of two or more adjacent ice crystals to form a single, larger crystal. Migratory recrystallisation, or Ostwald ripening, involves melting of smaller crystals and movement of the melted liquid to the surface of larger crystals28 30. At higher temperatures, smaller ice crystals melt partially or completely and when the temperature is lowered again, the water refreezes on the larger crystals31.
Migratory recrystallisation is influenced greatly by the rate at which the water molecules diffuse, or move, to the larger ice crystal surface, which is known as diffusion kinetics. The diffusion, or movement, of the water is largely dependent on the viscosity of the serum phase: as the viscosity of the unfrozen serum phase increases, the diffusion of water molecules decreases, thus retarding ice crystal growth32. Research suggests that inulin and oligofructose may extend the shelf life of ice cream through their capacity to retain and bind water, as well their ability to enhance the viscosity of the unfrozen serum phase, thus decreasing the diffusion of water molecules and retarding ice crystal growth33 18. Long-chain high DP inulin exhibits better shelf life extension potential compared to oligofructose34.
3. Health-promoting properties
In addition to the functional properties listed above, inulin and oligofructose have several important health-promoting properties. These include a prebiotic effect, suitability for diabetics, a reduction in the risk of diarrhea, constipation, colon and breast cancer, osteoporosis, and heart disease, immunomodulatory effects, regulation of serum cholesterol and triglyceride levels, improvement of calcium absorption, reduced plasma glucose levels, and anti-inflammatory and anti-cariogenic properties45.
3.1 Prebiotic
The term ‘prebiotic’ was introduced by Gibson and Roberfroid in 1995 to describe ‘a nondigestible food ingredient that beneficially affects the host by selectively stimulating the growth and/or activity of one or a limited number of bacteria in the colon, and thus improves the host’s health’35.
The colon is colonised by a complex ecosystem of bacteria. Some strains have potentially harmful effects, such as the production of toxins and carcinogens, whereas others are considered to provide a health-promoting function. Nourishing beneficial bacteria, such as Lactobacilli and Bifidobacteria, with inulin stimulates their growth and surprises the viability of potentially harmful bacteria, such as Escherichia coli, Campylobacteri jejuni, Enterobacterium spp. Salmonella enteritis, and others45, thereby improving the health of the host.
3.1.1 Short-chain and long-chain blend
Several nutritional studies (43 44) recommend the use of blends of short- and long-chain inulin to maximise fermentative and prebiotic effects because they are selectively metabolised in different portions of the large intestine (short-chain inulin in the proximal colon and long-chain inulin in more distal colonic regions). A 50:50 blend of short- and long-chain inulin also enhances calcium absorption and bone mineralisation in children46 and proves effective in reducing the amount of gas produced while increasing or maintaining its prebiotic effect47.
3.1.2 What is the recommended daily intake?
Although there is no daily recommended amount for prebiotics, at least 4 g per day, but preferably 8 g per day, of inulin is needed to significantly increase bifidobacteria in the human gut48 49.
3.2 Use by diabetics
Due to the non-digestability of inulin and oligofructose, they are suitable for consumption by diabetics. Researchers found no influence on serum glucose, no stimulation of insulin secretion and no influence on glucagon secretion36 37.
4. Negative effects of overconsumption
In general, there are no safety concerns with the ingestion of inulin or oligofructose, but excessive intake may cause undesirable side effects, including flatulance, laxation, and abdominal discomfort. Slower fermenting compounds are more easily tolerated than faster ones. Long-chain inulin is, therefore, better tolerated than short-chain oligofructose since it is fermented at a rate that is about 50% lower than that of oligofructose38 39.
Havenaar (2000)40 reviewed studies in humans and concluded that in adults, up to 20 g per day of inulin with an average DP of 9 does not cause serious adverse side effects, except mild to moderate discomfort such as flatulance in some individuals. The tolerance of moderate doses (5g to 10 g per day) of oligofructose was confirmed in 2 randomised controlled trials (41 42).
5. Summary
Inulin is a natural component of several fruits and vegetables, including leeks, onions, garlic, asparagus, Jerusalem artichokes, bananas, dahlias, yacon, and chicory. Several different commercial grades are available, the most commonly used being oligofructose, native inulin, and long-chain inulin. Oligofructose has a sweetness profile similar to that of table sugar and is about 30% – 50% as sweet. It is used in ice cream primarily as a low-calorie sugar substitute with research showing that 30% of the sucrose can be replaced with an equivalent amount of oligofructose. Native inulin has 10% of the sweetness of table sugar and is used primarily as a fat replacer in the formulation of low- or reduced-fat ice cream; 5% native inulin has been successfully used to reduce the fat content of a yog-ice cream by 50%. Long-chain HP inulin is the most desirable as a fat replacer. It does not contribute any sweetness and has double the fat-mimetic property of native inulin.
Oligofructose, native inulin, and long-chain inulin are low caloric food ingredients with a lower caloric value (2 kcal/g) compared to fat (9.45 kcal/g) and sucrose (4 kcal/g). As well as their fat and sugar replacement properties, oligofructose, native inulin, and long-chain inulin decrease the hardness of low-fat ice cream, produce a smoother and creamier texture, increase air incorporation (overrun) and melting resistance, and extend shelf-life.
In addition to their functional properties, oligofructose, native inulin, and long-chain inulin have several important health-promoting properties, including a prebiotic effect, suitability for diabetics, a reduction in the risk of diarrhea, constipation, colon and breast cancer, osteoporosis, and heart disease, immunomodulatory effects, regulation of serum cholesterol and triglyceride levels, improvement of calcium absorption, reduced plasma glucose levels, and anti-inflammatory and anti-cariogenic properties.
The consumption of up to 20 g per day of native and long-chain inulin, and 5g to 10 g per day of oligofructose, are well tolerated by adults. Overconsumption may, however, cause undesirable side effects, including flatulance, laxation, and abdominal discomfort.
6. References
[1]: Van Loo, J., Coussement, P., De Leenheer, L., Hoebregs, H., and Smits, G., 1995. On the presence of inulin and oligofructose as natural ingredients in the Western diet. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 35. 525–552.
[2]: Moshfegh, A. J., Friday, J. E., Goldman, J. P., and Chug Ahuja, J. K., 1999. Presence of inulin and oligofructose in the diets of Americans. Journal of Nutrition, 129. 7S. 1407–1411.
[3]: US Food and Drug Administration, 2003. Agency Response Letter GRAS Notice. No GRN 000118. Available at https://wayback.archive-it.org/7993/20171031022848/https://www.fda.gov/Food/IngredientsPackagingLabeling/GRAS/NoticeInventory/ucm153932.htm
[4]: Van Loo, J., 2006. Inulin-type Fructans as Prebiotics. In Gibson, G. R., and Rastall, R. A., (Eds), Prebiotics: Development and Application. Wiley and Sons Ltd.
[5]: Niness, K. R., 1999. Inulin and oligofructose: What are they? Journal of Nutrition, 129(Suppl. 7), 1402–1406.
[6]: Soukoulis, C., Rontogianni, E., and Tzia, C., 2010. Contribution of thermal, rheological and physical measurements to the determination of sensorially perceived quality of ice cream containing bulk sweeteners. Journal of Food Engineering, 100. 634-641.
[7]: Franck, A., 1993. Rafticreming: The new process allowing to turn fat into dietary fiber. FIE Conference Proceedings. 1992, pp.193–197. Maarssen: Expoconsult Publishers.
[8]: Bot, A., Erle, U., Vreeker, R., and Agterof, W. G. M., 2004. Influence of crystallisation conditions on the large deformation rheology of inulin gels. Food Hydrocolloids, 18. 547–556.
[9]: Pintor, A., Escalona-Buendia, H. B., and Totosaus, A., 2017. Effect of inulin on melting and textural properties of low-fat and sugar-reduced ice cream: optimization via a response surface methodology. International Food Research Journal, 24(4). 1728-1734.
[10]: El-Nagar, G., Glowes, G., Tudorica, C. M., Kuri, V., and Brennan, C. S., 2002. Rheological quality and stability of tog-ice cream with added inulin. International Journal of Dairy Technology, vol 55. 2.
[11]: European Commission. 2008. Commission Directive 2008/100/EC of 28 October 2008 amending Council Directive 90/496/EEC on nutrition labeling for foodstuffs as regards recommended daily allowances, energy conversion factors and definitions.
[12]: European Food Safety Authority. 2010. Scientific opinion on dietary reference values for carbohydrates and dietary fibre. European Food Safety Authority Journal, 8. 1464. 1–17.
[13]: Health Canada. 2012. Policy for labeling and advertising of dietary fibrecontaining food products. Available from: http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/fn-an /legislation/pol/fibre-label-etiquetage-eng.php.
[14]: US Food and Drug Administration. 2018. The declaration of certain isolated or synthetic non-digestible carbohydrates as dietary fibre on nutrition and supplement facts labels. Available at https://www.fda.gov/media/113663/download
[15]: Goff, H. D., and Hartel R. W., 2013. Ice Cream. Seventh Edition. New York: Springer.
[16]: Akalin, A. S., and Erisir, D., 2008. Effects of inulin and Oligofructose on the Rheological Characteristics and Probiotic Culture Survival in Low-Fat Probiotic Ice Cream. Journal of Food Science, vol. 73.
[17]: Akin, M. B., Akin, M. S., and Kirmaci, Z., 2007. Effects of inulin and sugar levels on the viability of yogurt and probiotic bacteria and the physical and sensory characteristics in probiotic ice cream. Food Chemistry, 104. 93-99.
[18]: Soukoulis, C., Lebesi, D., and Tzia, C., 2009. Enrichment of ice cream with dietary fibre: Effects on rheological properties, ice crystallisation and glass transition phonemena. Food Chemistry, 115. 665-671.
[19]: Schmidt, K. A., Lundy, A., Reynolds, J., and Yee, L. N., 1993. Carbohydrate or protein based fat mimicker effects on ice milk properties. Journal of Food Science, 58, 761–763.
[20]: Wada, T., Sugatani, J., Terada, E., Ohguchi, M., and Miwa, M., 2005.
Physicochemical characterization and biological effects of inulin
enzymatically synthesized from sucrose. Journal of Agricultural and
Food Chemistry, 53, 1246–1253.
[21]: Villegas, B., and Costell, E., 2007. Flow behaviour of inulin-milk beverages. Influence of inulin average chain length and of milk fat content. International Dairy Journal. 776-781.
[22]: Arcia, P. L., Costell, E., and Tarrega, A., 2011. Inulin blend as prebiotic and fat replacer in dairy desserts: Optimization by response surface methodology. Journal of Dairy Science, 94. 2192-2200.
[23]: Akalin, A. S., Karagozlu, C., and Unal, G., 2008. Rheological properties of reduced-fat and low-fat ice cream containing whey protein isolate and inulin. European Food Research and Technology, 227:889-895.
[24]: Karaca, O. B., Guven, M., Yasar, K., Kaya, S., and Kahyaoglu, T., 2009. The functional, rheological and sensory characteristics of ice creams with various fat replacers. International Journal of Dairy Technology, vol. 62.
[25]: Chang, Y., and Hartel, R. W., 2002. Stability of air cells in ice cream during hardening and storage. Journal of Food Engineering, 55:59–70.
[26]: Donhowe, D. P., Hartel R. W., and Bradley R.L., 1991. Determination of ice crystal size distributions in frozen desserts. Journal of Dairy Science, 74.
[27]: Drewett, E. M., and Hartel, R. W., 2007. Ice crystallisation in a scraped surface freezer. Journal of Food Engineering, 78(3).
[28]: Fennema, O. R., Powrie, W. D., and Marth, E. H., 1973. Low Temperature Preservation of Foods and living Matter. USA: Marcel Dekker, Inc.
[29]: Cook, K. L.K and Hartel, R. W., 2010. Mechanisms of ice crystallization in ice cream production. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and food Safety, vol. 9.
[30]: Donhowe, D. P., and Hartel, R. W., 1996. Recrystallization of ice in ice cream during controlled accelerated storage. International DairyJournal, 6(11-12):1191-208.
[31]: Sutton, R., and Bracey, J., 1996. The blast factor. Dairy Industries International, 61(2):31-33.
[32]: Bolliger, S., Wildmoser, H., Goff, H. D., and Tharp, B. W., 2000. Relationships between ice cream mix viscosity and ice crystal growth in ice cream. International Dairy Journal, 10, 791-797.
[33]: Schaller-Povolny, L. A. and Smith, D. E., 2001. Viscosity and freezing point of a reduced fat ice cream as related to inulin content. Milchwissenschaft, 56:25–9.
[34]: Soukoulis, C., Fisk, I. D., and Bohn, T., 2014. Ice Cream as a Vehicle for Incorporating Health-Promoting Ingredients: Conceptualization and Overview of Quality and Storage Stability. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, vol. 13.
[35]: Gibson, G. R., and Roberfroid, M. B., 1995. Dietary modulation of the human colonic microbiota: introducing the concept of prebiotics. Journal of Nutrition. 125:1401–1412.
[36]: Beringer, A., and Wenger, R., 1995. Inulin in der erna¨ hrung des diabetikers. Dtsch. Z. Verdauungs Stofwechselkrankh, 15. 268–272.
[37]: Sanno, T., Ishikawa, M., Nozawa, Y., Hoshi, K., and Someya, K., 1984. Application of Neosugar P for diabetic subjects. The effect of Neosugar P on blood glucose. Proc. 2nd Neosugar Research Conference, Tokyo, Japan.
[38]: Roberfroid, M. B., van Loo, J., and Gibson, G. R., 1998. The bifidogenic nature of chicory inulin and its hydrolysis products. Journal of Nutrition, 128:11–9.
[39]: Coussement, P. A. A., 1999. Inulin and oligofructose: safe intakes and legal status. Journal of Nutrition, 129:1412S–7.
[40]: Havenaar, R., 2000. Scientific evidence for beneficial effects of inulin DP9 on the intestinal flora of humans. Zeist, The Netherlands: TNO Nutrition and Food Research. Report no. V2537.
[41]: Bonnema, A. G., Kolberg, L. W., Thomas, W., and Slavin, J. L., 2010. Gastrointestinal tolerance of chicory inulin products. Journal of American Dietetic Association, 110:865–8.
[42]: Holscher, H. D., Doligale, J. L., Bauer, L. L., Gourineni, V., Pelkman, C. L., Fahey, G. C., and Swanson, K. S., 2014. Gastrointestinal tolerance and utilization of agave inulin by healthy adults. Food and Function, 5:1142–9.
[43]: Coudray, C., Tressol, J. C., Gueux, E., and Rayssiguier, Y., 2003. Effects
of inulin-type fructans of different chain length and type of branching on intestinal absorption and balance of calcium and magnesium in rats. European Journal of Nutrition. Eur. 42:91–98.
[44]: Biedrzycka, E., and Bielecka, M., 2004. Prebiotic effectiveness of fructans of different degrees of polymerization. Trends in Food Science and Technology. 15:170–175.
[45]: Saad, N., Delattre, C., Urdaci, M., Schmitter, J. M., and Bressollier, P. 2013. An overview of the last advances in probiotic and prebiotic field. LWT – Food Science and Technology. 50:1–16.
[46]: Abrams, S. A., Griffin, I. J., Hawthorne, K. M., Liang, L., Gunn, S. K., and Darlington, G., 2005. A combination of prebiotic short- and long-chain inulin-type fructans enhances calcium absorption and bone mineralization in young adolescents. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 82:471–476.
[47]: Ghoddusi, H. B., Grandison, M. A., Grandison, A. S., and Tuohy, K. M., 2007. In vitro study on gas generation and prebiotic effects of some carbohydrates and their mixtures. Anaerobe. 13:193–199.
[48]: Manning, T. S., and Gibson, G. R., 2004. Microbial-gut interactions in health and disease. Prebiotics. Best Pract. Res. Clin. Gastroenterol. 18:287–298.
[49]: Langlands, S. J., Hopkins, M. J., Coleman, N., and Cummings, J. H., 2004. Prebiotics carbohydrates modify the mucosa associated microflora of the human large bowel. Gut. 53:1610–1616.
[50]: Akbari, M., Eskandari, H., Niakosari, M., and Bedeltavana, A., 2016. The effect of inulin on the physicochemical properties and sensory attributes of low-fat ice cream. International Dairy Journal, 57, 52-55.
[51]: Meyer, D., and Blaauwhoed, J. P., 2009. Inulin. In Phillips, G. O., and Willaims, P. A. (Eds), Handbook of hydrocolloids. Second Edition. Woodhead Publishing.
